Showing posts with label GAO report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GAO report. Show all posts

Friday, June 22, 2012

Dalton couple stuck in Mexico over immigration issue




DALTON, GA (WRCB) -- Angie Carranza admits her family brought her here illegally when she was a child. Now she's a working adult, and married, and wants to get on the right path to citizenship, but she could be stuck in Mexico for a decade.

Angie was brought here when she was just five. Every memory she has, is growing up in Dalton. She started the process of getting a visa, but going the legal route seems to have back-fired.

The couple talked to us via Skype from Mexico -- the place immigration officials say is Angie Carranza's home.

"Dalton is my home. I grew up there. That's the home I know," Angie Carranza said.

Angie and husband Ramon Gonzalez went to Mexico two months ago to finally get Angie a visa, so she wouldn't have to worry about being here illegally. It's something that's held her back her whole life.

"On that plane ride to Juarez, I thought to myself, this is the beginning of some great for me," Angie said.

She says her lawyers were confident she'd be approved for a visa since her parents brought her to the U.S. illegally, but she was denied. "I never realized I was committing a crime. I don't blame my parents for what's happening to me. I thank them. I thank them very much because I grew up having a great education. I grew up having freedom," Angie said.

Despite being a good student and having a clean record, she's banned from the U.S. for 10 years. That's because not only did she enter the country illegally once as a 5-year-old, but a second time when she was 13 and returned from a short trip after visiting her dying grandfather.

Two appeals have already been denied, but Ramon is not coming back until Angie can. "I can't leave her here by herself," Ramon said.

Meanwhile, Ramon's mom is back in Dalton left to run the family business alone. "I'm desperate. I'm devastated," Ramon's mom, Martha Gonzalez, said.

She brought him to the U.S. legally for a better life and is heartbroken he's stuck there. "It's hard to see that you fight for something so hard and then you see your children's life is not going that way," Martha said.

As Angie waits to hear from the consulate general. She and Ramon are staying with a family member who was deported for a similar reason.

She hopes her story will bring attention to the issues people in her position face with current immigration laws and that she can inspire politicians to get behind reform.


And showing how difficult the issue is for everyone to deal with, U.S. Senators Johnny Isakson, R-Ga., and Saxby Chambliss, R-Ga. sent the following letter to President Obama on the immigration issue:

Dear President Obama:

We are extremely concerned by your announcement last week that the Department of Homeland Security plans to implement a program that grants deferred action to an untold number of illegal immigrants in the United States, and to allow them to receive work authorization during this time of record unemployment. Not only do we question your legal authority to act unilaterally in this regard, we are frustrated that you have intentionally bypassed Congress and the American people.

As President, you swore to uphold and defend the Constitution and enforce the laws. Your recently announced directive runs contrary to that responsibility. Not only is your directive an affront to our system of representative government and the legislative process, but it is an inappropriate use of Executive power.

Your position on whether you have the legal authority to act unilaterally has changed dramatically. Just last year, you personally disputed the notion that the Executive Branch could act on its own and grant benefits to a certain class of illegal immigrants. Specifically, you stated,

"This notion that somehow I can just change the laws unilaterally is just not true. The fact of the matter is there are laws on the books that I have to enforce. And I think there's been a great disservice done to the cause of getting the DREAM Act passed and getting comprehensive immigration passed by perpetrating the notion that somehow, by myself, I can go and do these things. It's just not true. We live in a democracy. You have to pass bills through the legislature, and then I can sign it."

- Why has your position on the legal authority of the Executive Branch changed?
- Did you consult with attorneys prior to the announcement about your legal authority to grant deferred action and work authorizations to a specific class of illegal immigrants?
- Did you obtain a legal opinion from the Office of Legal Counsel or anyone else in the administration about your legal authority to implement such a program?
- Please provide copies of any documentation, including any and all legal opinions, memoranda, and emails, that discusses any authority you have or do not have to undertake this immigration directive.

We are also concerned that the directive being implemented allows individuals under the age of 30 to obtain a work authorization. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate for young adults aged 16-24 has been nearly 17% for the last year. According to a Gallup poll conducted in April of this year, 32% of 18 to 29 year-olds in the U.S. workforce were underemployed. Your directive runs contrary to the premise that American workers must come before foreign nationals. It is astonishing that your administration would grant work authorizations to illegal immigrants during this time of record unemployment. Your directive will only increase competition for American students and workers who struggle to find employment in today's economy. Moreover, under current law, some foreign students and other legal visa holders are prohibited from obtaining work authorizations, giving illegal immigrants an advantage over those who play by the rules.

The implementation of your directive raises several serious questions.

- What will happen if your directive is challenged in court?
- Will individuals who have applied for deferred action be required to leave the U.S. if such a challenge is upheld?
- How will the administration handle family members, specifically the parents who violated federal immigration law?
- Will individuals who entered the U.S. on their own volition – either by crossing the border illegally or overstaying a visa – be eligible for deferred action?
- Why does the directive allow individuals up to age 30 to benefit from deferred action if the directive is aimed at helping young people and students?
- How will federal officials who process the applications ensure that information provided by the individual is accurate and how will they verify that one truly entered the country before the age of 16 or are currently under the age of 30?
- Will evidence submitted in support of deferred action applications be limited to independently verifiable government-issued documents (e.g., school records, W-2s, tax returns)? If not, why not? If affidavits will be accepted, will they be required to be made under penalty of perjury? If not, why not?
- Will illegal immigrants be required to appear in person for an interview by the federal government before deferred action is granted?
- How will the agency implementing the program ensure that fraud and abuse is prevented?
- What will the consequences be for individuals who intentionally defraud the government?
- Which databases will be used and how will background checks be conducted to ensure that individuals do not have a criminal history or pose a threat to public safety?
- What would constitute a "significant" misdemeanor offense, which is one of the criteria for eligibility for deferred status?
- Will individuals with final orders of removal be eligible for deferred action?
- What action will the administration take if an individual is denied deferred action?
- What action will be taken if an individual is granted deferred action, but subsequently abuses that grant, is arrested, is found to be a member of a criminal gang, or does not actually attend school?
- Absent congressional action, what will happen in two years to the individuals who are granted deferred action?
- Will recipients of deferred action be eligible for receipt of advance parole?
- What criteria will be used to decide who gets work authorizations and who does not?
- Which other departments and agencies will be consulted and will work with the Department of Homeland Security on the implementation of this directive?

We also believe that taxpayers deserve to know how this program will be funded.

Can you assure us that the total implementation cost of the program will be paid for by the individuals seeking to benefit, or will U.S. taxpayers subsidize any part of the program?

- How much, if anything, will an illegal immigrant be required to pay in order to obtain deferred action?
- What legal authority does the Executive Branch have to mandate a fee for this service? We understand that the Department has never previously charged a fee for the processing of a request for deferred action.
- Do you plan to reprogram funds at the Department of Homeland Security or any other Executive Branch agency to help fund the implementation of the directive?
- If you plan to use funds that already have been appropriated or other funds from the Department, please explain which programs will be reduced in order to cover the costs associated with the directive.
- If USCIS adjudications staff will be diverted from their normal duties to handle the millions of potential deferred action applications, what will be the impact on other USCIS programs?

Given that this directive is effective immediately and that many questions remain unanswered, we ask that you immediately make available Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Director John Morton and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service Director Alejandro Mayorkas to respond to our concerns. We would appreciate responses to our questions, including any relevant documentation related to this directive, no later than July 3, 2012.

Friday, December 2, 2011

Malaysia swap deal remains ALP policy

The ALP has backed a huge boost to the nation's refugee intake while maintaining a controversial plan to process asylum seekers offshore under a deal with Malaysia.

Immigration Minister Chris Bowen's proposal to keep the people-swap deal as party policy and increase the refugee intake to 20,000 a year, from 13,750, was accepted at the ALP national conference in Sydney on Saturday.

"We have to tackle this with a soft heart and a hard head," Mr Bowen said.

Home Affairs Minister Brendan O'Connor told delegates that boat people smugglers were "not modern-day Oskar Schindlers" - a reference to the German industrialist credited with saving more than 1100 Jews during World War II.

"Nothing could be further from the truth," he said.

"This is profiting from desperate people. This is exploitation whatever way you cut it."

Under the deal announced in May, Australia would send 800 asylum seekers to Malaysia for processing and receive 4000 people already judged to be genuine refugees.

But the High Court has ruled offshore processing is illegal and the government has not had the numbers to change the law.

The Gillard government has now adopted onshore processing and community detention as a default position.

After the conference vote, Mr Bowen admitted the result did not mean Opposition Leader Tony Abbott would support the government's policy.

"Any complaints about boat arrivals are particularly hollow when the (opposition) have a solution before them," he told reporters.

Opposition immigration spokesman Scott Morrison said the government's asylum seeker policy had failed and any policy decisions taken by the ALP national conference would not change that.

He dismissed Mr Bowen's proposal as "a desperate plan to a divided party for a failed Malaysia people-swap".

Meanwhile, an alternative proposal from the Labor Left to scrap offshore processing of asylum seekers was beaten.

Backbencher Melissa Parke told the conference the Malaysia deal fundamentally discriminated against the human rights of asylum seekers.

"Australia cannot contract out its international legal obligations," she said.

Ms Parke said it was irresponsible to send asylum seekers to a country that did not recognise refugees.

Australian Manufacturing Workers Union organiser Darren Dwyer said the debate was about human rights, not "some pinko ideology".

He said he felt ashamed to be a Labor member.

The Bowen proposal was supported 206-179.

Cepeda: Gingrich’s tightrope walk

Moments after the last Republican presidential candidate debate ended, the ever-breathless blogosphere started wondering if Newt Gingrich was making a play for the Latino vote with his controversial remarks about being humane to America's 11 million illegal immigrants.

Of course he was. Gingrich may be many things — a highly paid consultant to eyebrow-raising clients, a philanderer and a prolific, if ungifted, author — but he's not ignorant of Hispanic voting power.

For the past few years, Gingrich has been working overtime to eradicate the fallout from his infamous 2007 speech to the National Federation of Republican Women when he said Spanish was "the language of living in a ghetto."
"Whether you are first-, second-, third- or fourth-generation Hispanic — or whether you speak English or Spanish or both," the website's "About Us" page says, "our content is catered to what unites us all, which is our American Hispanic Heritage."

Last December, "The Americano" had its first national forum, pulling together a who's who of Hispanic conservatives to discuss a variety of leadership topics, including immigration and national security, which no doubt provided much input to Gingrich's immigration stance. The event got big play on Latino traditional and social media.

So there's no mistaking that Gingrich has been diligently courting Latino voters. But doing that while still convincing the far-right wing of the Republican Party that he's not a "Republican in name only" because of his centrist immigration views is a difficult tightrope to walk.

Unfortunately for Gingrich, the only immigration view most people seem to be able to agree on is that the 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli amnesty didn't work. And though immigration is not the top concern for Latino or other voters, it provokes the strongest emotions from both sides. As a result, because Gingrich's immigration "solutions" are largely moderate and reasonable, they are the antithesis of what the vocal extremes deem acceptable.

Every plank of his treatise can be ardently disputed by both sides. For instance, Gingrich's No. 1 priority is for the border to be "controlled." But while ultra-liberals, citing the unprecedented show of force at the border and record number of deportations, scoff at what they see as an accomplished goal, ultra-conservatives refuse to consider any other aspects of immigration law reform until there is an air-tight seal between the U.S. and the rest of the world.
We could pingpong Gingrich's other points, too: Visa and guest-worker programs seem to be held in equally low regard by both sides, though for different reasons, and neither side seems willing to entertain a permanent noncitizen "legal" status. As I recall, there was practically a second civil war the last time anyone seriously suggested, as Gingrich does, that our country's official language should be English.

If we've learned anything in the last few years, it's that neither the far right nor the far left wants compromise — their arguments are framed only as triumphant wins or tragic losses. This makes Gingrich's middle-ground stance his greatest weakness concerning the immigration issue.

After the debate, his campaign was diligently tweeting out the link to his official immigration platform, "10 Steps to a Legal Nation." Since winning the endorsement of The Union Leader, New Hampshire's largest newspaper, Gingrich's website's home page has prominently featured the news headline "Newt's Plan to Secure the Border First," and this has become the talking point du jour.

Who can blame him? Taking the middle ground on immigration is like setting up shop in Death Valley. The end of the balancing act has already begun. Watch for Gingrich to leap off the tightrope with a hard-right lurch.

Unlike other Republicans who combine their desire for small government and low taxes with a head-on-fire dislike of illegal immigrants, Gingrich has gone in the opposite direction of the hard-liners and built some platforms on which to gamely court Latinos.

In September 2009, he started up "The Americano," a bilingual news and opinion site geared toward "celebrating Latino heritage and conservatism in America." Founded and edited by Sylvia Garcia, a longtime Gingrich Communications employee who had also overseen his Spanish-language website, the site launched with the aim of being "inclusive of all americanos that have come to live to the United States."

Obama puts pressure on Republicans on immigration reform

WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama urged Americans on Tuesday to help him push Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform — a divisive issue that lawmakers have been unwilling to take up in recent years.

“I am asking you to add your voices to this debate,” Obama said in a speech near the U.S.-Mexico border in El Paso. “We need Washington to know that there is a movement for reform gathering strength from coast to coast. That’s how we’ll get this done.”

The president said reform should include efforts to secure the border, crack down on businesses that exploit undocumented workers, and require the nearly 11 million immigrants in this country illegally to pay fines and back taxes, learn English and undergo background checks before they can apply for legal status. He also said American farmers need a legal way to hire immigrant workers.

Children of illegal aliens should be allowed to become U.S. citizens if they go to college or join the U.S. military, Obama said. He said he will continue to support DREAM Act legislation, as it’s known, aimed at helping those young immigrants. The full name is Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors.

Critics said the president knows reform efforts are going nowhere in a politically divided Congress and is just trying to rally Hispanic voters to help him win re-election in 2012. Obama received more than 65 percent of the Hispanic vote in 2008.

“President Obama’s immigration speech today was driven by politics and politics alone,” said Rep. Ben Quayle, R-Ariz. “Instead of real solutions and reforms, the president offered finger-pointing and spin.”

Supporters applauded him, saying he’s taking a leadership role on the issue and articulating his plan to fix the nation’s broken immigration system.

“I’m pleased the president laid out a blueprint for comprehensive immigration reform that tackles the problem from all fronts,” said Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev.

Immigrant rights’ groups have been pressing Obama to take the lead on the issue for more than two years, and the president could no longer sidestep the issue, political scientists said.

“He can’t duck this issue just because Congress can’t figure out what to do,” said Eric Herzik, chairman of the political science department at the University of Nevada, Reno. “Nothing may happen from his proposals, but then the Congress has to explain that to voters — as much if not more so than President Obama.”

Herzik said Obama is trying to stake out a moderate position between liberals, who call for blanket amnesty and an end to all deportations, and conservatives, who want to pass tough Arizona-style enforcement laws that target illegal immigrants.

“Obama has to find a middle ground,” the professor said.

Obama’s blueprint for reform echoed efforts by Senate leaders in the last Congress to come up with a framework for legislation. That bill died when Republicans and conservative Democrats balked at taking up the controversial issue in an election year. Last-minute efforts to pass the DREAM Act at the end of 2010 also failed.

The president said it is time for Republicans to return to the negotiating table instead of calling for more border security measures.

Republicans say the border must be enforced before anything else changes.

Obama touted his administration’s efforts to secure the Southwest border by increasing the number of Border Patrol agents to about 20,000, deploying unmanned surveillance aircraft from Texas to California, and forging new alliances with Mexico to combat drug cartels.

“We have gone above and beyond what was requested by the very Republicans who said they supported broader reform as long as we got serious about enforcement,” Obama said. “But even though we’ve answered these concerns, I suspect there will be those who will try to move the goal posts one more time. They’ll say we need to triple the border patrol. Or quadruple the border patrol. They’ll say we need a higher fence to support reform.

“Maybe they’ll say we need a moat,” Obama joked. “Or alligators in the moat. They’ll never be satisfied. And I understand that. That’s politics.”

But members of Congress from Southwest border states said their call for more security measures is based on real dangers faced by their constituents amid escalating violence by Mexican drug cartels.

Instead of pushing for comprehensive reform, Obama should endorse a $4 billion bill to put 6,000 National Guard troops and 5,000 more Border Patrol agents on the border, said Arizona Republican Sens. John McCain and Jon Kyl, co-sponsors of the Border Security Enforcement Act.

“President Obama speaks about our broken immigration system,but what about our broken borders?” McCain and Kyl said in a joint statement. “During the president’s first visit to our nation’s southern border, we hope he will finally see first-hand the continued security challenges facing all of those who live along our southwest border. We hear from our constituents on a daily basis, and, while some progress has been made in some areas, they do not believe the border is secure. In fact, a recent GAO report confirmed that the Border Patrol has operational control of only 44 percent of the southwest border

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More

 
Design by Free WordPress Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha - Premium Blogger Themes | GreenGeeks Review